So, if you've read my blog for long, you'll know that I am a big fan of the Alice series by Phyllis Reynolds Naylor. It had taken me a long time to get to Outrageously Alice and I had been looking forward to reading it. This is another book that I will blog about sooner or later, so I won't spend too much time talking about it now.
But here are the things that stood out for me in this reading. Alice lives with her father and her older brother. There is such a remarkable relationship between the three of them - one that is so rare and fun. They are good to each other, and both her father and her brother have roles in raising Alice. Alice is curious, and there are lots of questions that she asks each of them (or both of them together!).
Also, in this book in the series, Alice is struggling with who she will be, both now and as a grown-up. She wants to be "not boring", which can sometimes cross the line into outrageous. She's also learning how to interact with boys, which is interesting too. As always with these books, there is lots to think and write about. I am looking forward to writing about this one on the blog too!!
Current Reading Time: 10.5 hours reading + 1 hour blogging - 11.5 hours total!!
Books Finished: 5
Outrageously Alice. Phyllis Reynolds Naylor. Simon and Schuster, 1997.
Now off to keep reading and I have a blog post to write for today!
Showing posts with label coming of age. Show all posts
Showing posts with label coming of age. Show all posts
Sunday, June 21, 2015
Sunday, May 13, 2012
Alice In-Between
So it's Mother's Day, for at least another hour here. I'm finally posting a blog for the first time in more than a month. Sorry for the long silence, but there have been some changes here, as well as some computer troubles that kept me from posting. But I'm back!
And I am writing today about Alice, who actually lost her mother when she was very young. If you haven't read my other posts on this series, you can start here. Alice begins this book at the end of her seventh grade year. She has "the in-between blues" (p.86) as she tells her brother Lester. Alice feels like she isn't young anymore, but she also isn't ready to become a grownup. After all, she is only just turning thirteen. And as those of us who have been thirteen year old girls can attest, quite often you don't know exactly what's going on. You yearn for change, but when it comes, you aren't really ready for it and then want to go back to childhood.
This is exactly what happens to Alice. She gets two glimpses of the adult world that giver her pause in this book. The first comes after Alice's birthday. For her birthday, she gets Lester to agree to take her out for a fancy (expensive) night on the town. While Alice and Lester are out dancing, they run into Lester's sometime girlfriend, Crystal. She has met a man at a club, and he has become aggressive with alcohol and won't leave her alone. This man believes that Lester and Alice are husband and wife, and he willingly dances with Alice while Lester smuggles Crystal out of the club. Alice marvels "I had only been a teenager for one week, and already I was being asked to help out in the romance department. More than that, I might even be saving Crystal's life." (p. 24). They make it out successfully, and the whole incident has a light-hearted tone. None of them ever really feel in danger, and they all laugh about it. After dropping Crystal off, though, Alice does ask Lester what she should do if it happens to her, and he tells her to call home immediately so he or their father can come get her. But Alice is flattered by being seen as older by this man, and excited by the adventure of rescuing Crystal.
The next incident is even more threatening and scary. Alice is invited to Chicago to visit her Aunt Sally's family with her two best friends, Pamela and Elizabeth. As a side note, this friendship is another place where Alice feels in-between. While Pamela loves to look more grown-up and to experiment with being adult, Elizabeth is prudish and young. She doesn't want to talk about anything having to do with boys, marriage or sex. Alice isn't quite ready to move full steam ahead like Pamela, is, but she isn't as slow to grow up as Elizabeth.
So off the girls go, via Amtrak from Washington DC to Chicago. They are going to spend the night on the train, and Pamela ends up with her own tiny room. A man sees her on the train, and asks her to eat dinner with him. Pamela, not thinking of the consequences, agrees. She tells him that she is getting ready to start college. After dinner (with multiple drinks for the man), they go back to her room, but luckily Pamela is able to escape before anything really terrible happens to her (he does kiss and grope her). The girls are lucky to have the conductor watching out for them, and he threatens the man to get him to leave the girls alone. All three girls are very shaken by this incident, and during their time in Chicago, Alice notices that Pamela is reverting: "I swear she looked more like her sixth-grade picture than she did back in sixth grade." (p.115). Not even Pamela is truly ready to become an adult.
As in most of the Alice books, Alice spends a lot of time thinking and wondering about her mother. She misses her mother, and wonders how she would be different if her mother was alive. And she sometimes feels a little lost with her father and brother: "One of the problems of growing up without a mother is that there's no one around who has any idea what it's like to be a girl." (p.2). As Alice continues to negotiate her way through puberty, I can see this only becoming more important to her.
While looking for a poem to recite in a poetry unit at school, she finds a poem in a book belonging to her mother. It's "Thanatopsis" by William Cullen Bryant, and a note in its margin tells Alice that it was one of her favorites. Alice begins to work on memorizing the poem, and in turn, this connects her to her father's grief. He helps Alice practice, and tells her how this poem helped sustain both Alice's mother and him while she was dying. On the day Alice recites the poem in class, she begins crying as she speaks, thinking of her mother's life and love. Later than night, she tells her brother and father about what happened. Lester tells about a letter their mother had written him before she died, and how he thought he had lost it at school afterwards. He tells how hard he had cried. "Dad reached over and put a hand on Lester's shoulder, then stretched out his other hand to me...for a moment we just sat there, all holding hands. Then Dad gave us a quick squeeze, and we went back to eating supper." (p. 85). It's a poignant moment of enduring grief, but also enduring family strength.
Alice is negotiating the difficulties of being a teenager fairly well. At the end of this book, Alice seems to be back together with Patrick, her on-again, off-again boyfriend. And she is coming into her own. There will always be bumps in the road, but Alice's Aunt Sally sums it up best when she says "'Marie's little girl, almost grown.'...'She would have been so pleased.'" (p. 120)
Alice In-Between. Phyllis Reynolds Naylor. Atheneum, 1994.
Borrowed from Lewis & Clark library
And I am writing today about Alice, who actually lost her mother when she was very young. If you haven't read my other posts on this series, you can start here. Alice begins this book at the end of her seventh grade year. She has "the in-between blues" (p.86) as she tells her brother Lester. Alice feels like she isn't young anymore, but she also isn't ready to become a grownup. After all, she is only just turning thirteen. And as those of us who have been thirteen year old girls can attest, quite often you don't know exactly what's going on. You yearn for change, but when it comes, you aren't really ready for it and then want to go back to childhood.
This is exactly what happens to Alice. She gets two glimpses of the adult world that giver her pause in this book. The first comes after Alice's birthday. For her birthday, she gets Lester to agree to take her out for a fancy (expensive) night on the town. While Alice and Lester are out dancing, they run into Lester's sometime girlfriend, Crystal. She has met a man at a club, and he has become aggressive with alcohol and won't leave her alone. This man believes that Lester and Alice are husband and wife, and he willingly dances with Alice while Lester smuggles Crystal out of the club. Alice marvels "I had only been a teenager for one week, and already I was being asked to help out in the romance department. More than that, I might even be saving Crystal's life." (p. 24). They make it out successfully, and the whole incident has a light-hearted tone. None of them ever really feel in danger, and they all laugh about it. After dropping Crystal off, though, Alice does ask Lester what she should do if it happens to her, and he tells her to call home immediately so he or their father can come get her. But Alice is flattered by being seen as older by this man, and excited by the adventure of rescuing Crystal.
The next incident is even more threatening and scary. Alice is invited to Chicago to visit her Aunt Sally's family with her two best friends, Pamela and Elizabeth. As a side note, this friendship is another place where Alice feels in-between. While Pamela loves to look more grown-up and to experiment with being adult, Elizabeth is prudish and young. She doesn't want to talk about anything having to do with boys, marriage or sex. Alice isn't quite ready to move full steam ahead like Pamela, is, but she isn't as slow to grow up as Elizabeth.
So off the girls go, via Amtrak from Washington DC to Chicago. They are going to spend the night on the train, and Pamela ends up with her own tiny room. A man sees her on the train, and asks her to eat dinner with him. Pamela, not thinking of the consequences, agrees. She tells him that she is getting ready to start college. After dinner (with multiple drinks for the man), they go back to her room, but luckily Pamela is able to escape before anything really terrible happens to her (he does kiss and grope her). The girls are lucky to have the conductor watching out for them, and he threatens the man to get him to leave the girls alone. All three girls are very shaken by this incident, and during their time in Chicago, Alice notices that Pamela is reverting: "I swear she looked more like her sixth-grade picture than she did back in sixth grade." (p.115). Not even Pamela is truly ready to become an adult.
As in most of the Alice books, Alice spends a lot of time thinking and wondering about her mother. She misses her mother, and wonders how she would be different if her mother was alive. And she sometimes feels a little lost with her father and brother: "One of the problems of growing up without a mother is that there's no one around who has any idea what it's like to be a girl." (p.2). As Alice continues to negotiate her way through puberty, I can see this only becoming more important to her.
While looking for a poem to recite in a poetry unit at school, she finds a poem in a book belonging to her mother. It's "Thanatopsis" by William Cullen Bryant, and a note in its margin tells Alice that it was one of her favorites. Alice begins to work on memorizing the poem, and in turn, this connects her to her father's grief. He helps Alice practice, and tells her how this poem helped sustain both Alice's mother and him while she was dying. On the day Alice recites the poem in class, she begins crying as she speaks, thinking of her mother's life and love. Later than night, she tells her brother and father about what happened. Lester tells about a letter their mother had written him before she died, and how he thought he had lost it at school afterwards. He tells how hard he had cried. "Dad reached over and put a hand on Lester's shoulder, then stretched out his other hand to me...for a moment we just sat there, all holding hands. Then Dad gave us a quick squeeze, and we went back to eating supper." (p. 85). It's a poignant moment of enduring grief, but also enduring family strength.
Alice is negotiating the difficulties of being a teenager fairly well. At the end of this book, Alice seems to be back together with Patrick, her on-again, off-again boyfriend. And she is coming into her own. There will always be bumps in the road, but Alice's Aunt Sally sums it up best when she says "'Marie's little girl, almost grown.'...'She would have been so pleased.'" (p. 120)
Alice In-Between. Phyllis Reynolds Naylor. Atheneum, 1994.
Borrowed from Lewis & Clark library
Wednesday, February 15, 2012
Alice in April
I've been reading my way through the Alice series for about 18 months now. They aren't the only thing I'm reading, as you can tell from my other entries. But every time I pick up a book from this series, I gulp them down in a very short amount of time. As I read, I fold down the corners of pages I want to go back to. When I'm done reading, there are usually many dog-eared pages throughout. There are so many ideas about growing up that really resonate with me, both remembering life as a young teenager and looking at Alice as an adult. That's why I'm always so pleased to share these with you - if just one teen reads this series because of my writing, I'll feel like I did my part!

Alice in April begins right before Alice turns 13. One of the most dated plot points in this novel (this was published almost 20 years ago, in 1993) involves Alice's Aunt Sally. Since Alice's mother died before Alice was even in Kindergarten, Aunt Sally is the closest thing Alice has to a mother. Sally advises Alice that as she turns 13, she will need to become the Woman of the House (capital letters intended), to support her older brother and father. Sally reminds Alice that Alice's mother was a homemaker. When Alice questions what a homemaker is, Sally "said a homemaker just makes a better home." (p.29). She also gives Alice a laundry list of tasks she needs to begin, including all of the mending. Eventually Alice's father discovers Alice's worries about being the Woman of the House, and reassures her that he does all the mending, and that no one needs to start spring cleaning just yet.
It is difficult for Alice to remember her mother, so she relies on other people's stories and memories of her. Often in the past Alice has told her father she remembers something about her mother, and it turns out she's really confusing her mother with her Aunt Sally, who helped care for Alice after her mother died. This is always painful for her father, and of course it's painful for Alice, too. She is constantly reminded that she is the one person who has no idea what her mother was like. That sort of mistaken memory is mentioned in every book - sometimes matter of factly, sometimes sadly. As readers, we have grown accustomed to this, and accept that Alice will not ever remember anything about her mother. So in Alice in April it is such a surprise, and such a gift, when Alice does finally remember something involving her mother. "The more I thought about that scene, the clearer it became. Yes, it was definitely my mother, and I remembered hugging her legs as we sat on those steps...." (p. 51). In the memory, a young Alice tells her mother that she will never marry, and stay with her mother forever. Her mother replies that Alice will find someone kind to love her. It's a little bit of throwaway wisdom that I'm sure Alice's mother never thought would become a treasured memory.
Alice has thought and talked about her mother's death in all of the books so far. This series is realistic in depicting Alice's grief. While her family moves on with their lives, they all feel their mother's absence. But in all of the previous novels, Alice has looked at her mother's death from her own sense of loss and perspective. In this story, Alice goes to get a physical, and has a shocking moment of recognition: "It was weird, but I suddenly thought about Mom just then - wondering if she'd been sitting in a doctor's office in a paper robe like this the day she found out she had leukemia." (p. 41). Alice is growing up, and this is just one way Naylor demonstrates that. It is only for a split second (just seven lines of text) that Alice puts herself in her mother's place. But it is poignant and heartbreaking and all too real. You really see her mother, sitting on the table. She has always been a shadowy character, since we can only know what Alice knows, but here she comes into sharp, tearful focus.
This isn't the only heartbreaking loss in Alice in April. Alice spends some time with Denise, who we originally met in Reluctantly Alice, two books ago. Denise began as a bully, but eventually she and Alice have become tentative friends. Alice knows that Denise's life at home isn't good. Denise shows up unannounced at Alice's house one night, and stays the night because she doesn't want to go home. When Alice's father can't reach Denise's family, he notifies the police that Denise is safe with them, but no one ever comes looking for Denise. Alice can tell Denise is hit on a regular basis, but doesn't question it. Denise shrugs it off, and seems to accept it. She tells Alice that her mother "won't change. That's the problem - no matter what I do, I can't win. (p.69). Alice shows empathy and compassion for Denise, and supports her as best as she can. But sadly, it isn't enough. Readers will be as shocked as Alice is to find out that Denise has committed suicide. I felt the impact of this act as I read - I hadn't seen it coming, as bad as Denise's life was. The school is told about Denise's death in an assembly, but Alice is in total shock. "He went on talking, but I didn't hear. I found myself crawling down through the seats in the bleachers, pushing aside people's feet to make room." (p. 155). For many students today, this is unfortunately something they've heard about either locally or on the news, but to see Alice experience it is still emotional and visceral. It leaves readers shaken.
Denise's death happens at the end of the book, and Alice definitely isn't okay by the final scene. She is contemplative, wondering what she could have done differently. In the end, she realizes "...all we can do is be the best friends to each other that we can and hope it's enough." (p.159). Growing up is never easy, and Naylor's willingness to share this struggle is just one of the things I love about this series.
Alice in April. Phyllis Reynolds Naylor. Atheneum Books for Young Readers, 1993.
borrowed from Lewis & Clark library
Alice in April begins right before Alice turns 13. One of the most dated plot points in this novel (this was published almost 20 years ago, in 1993) involves Alice's Aunt Sally. Since Alice's mother died before Alice was even in Kindergarten, Aunt Sally is the closest thing Alice has to a mother. Sally advises Alice that as she turns 13, she will need to become the Woman of the House (capital letters intended), to support her older brother and father. Sally reminds Alice that Alice's mother was a homemaker. When Alice questions what a homemaker is, Sally "said a homemaker just makes a better home." (p.29). She also gives Alice a laundry list of tasks she needs to begin, including all of the mending. Eventually Alice's father discovers Alice's worries about being the Woman of the House, and reassures her that he does all the mending, and that no one needs to start spring cleaning just yet.
It is difficult for Alice to remember her mother, so she relies on other people's stories and memories of her. Often in the past Alice has told her father she remembers something about her mother, and it turns out she's really confusing her mother with her Aunt Sally, who helped care for Alice after her mother died. This is always painful for her father, and of course it's painful for Alice, too. She is constantly reminded that she is the one person who has no idea what her mother was like. That sort of mistaken memory is mentioned in every book - sometimes matter of factly, sometimes sadly. As readers, we have grown accustomed to this, and accept that Alice will not ever remember anything about her mother. So in Alice in April it is such a surprise, and such a gift, when Alice does finally remember something involving her mother. "The more I thought about that scene, the clearer it became. Yes, it was definitely my mother, and I remembered hugging her legs as we sat on those steps...." (p. 51). In the memory, a young Alice tells her mother that she will never marry, and stay with her mother forever. Her mother replies that Alice will find someone kind to love her. It's a little bit of throwaway wisdom that I'm sure Alice's mother never thought would become a treasured memory.
Alice has thought and talked about her mother's death in all of the books so far. This series is realistic in depicting Alice's grief. While her family moves on with their lives, they all feel their mother's absence. But in all of the previous novels, Alice has looked at her mother's death from her own sense of loss and perspective. In this story, Alice goes to get a physical, and has a shocking moment of recognition: "It was weird, but I suddenly thought about Mom just then - wondering if she'd been sitting in a doctor's office in a paper robe like this the day she found out she had leukemia." (p. 41). Alice is growing up, and this is just one way Naylor demonstrates that. It is only for a split second (just seven lines of text) that Alice puts herself in her mother's place. But it is poignant and heartbreaking and all too real. You really see her mother, sitting on the table. She has always been a shadowy character, since we can only know what Alice knows, but here she comes into sharp, tearful focus.
This isn't the only heartbreaking loss in Alice in April. Alice spends some time with Denise, who we originally met in Reluctantly Alice, two books ago. Denise began as a bully, but eventually she and Alice have become tentative friends. Alice knows that Denise's life at home isn't good. Denise shows up unannounced at Alice's house one night, and stays the night because she doesn't want to go home. When Alice's father can't reach Denise's family, he notifies the police that Denise is safe with them, but no one ever comes looking for Denise. Alice can tell Denise is hit on a regular basis, but doesn't question it. Denise shrugs it off, and seems to accept it. She tells Alice that her mother "won't change. That's the problem - no matter what I do, I can't win. (p.69). Alice shows empathy and compassion for Denise, and supports her as best as she can. But sadly, it isn't enough. Readers will be as shocked as Alice is to find out that Denise has committed suicide. I felt the impact of this act as I read - I hadn't seen it coming, as bad as Denise's life was. The school is told about Denise's death in an assembly, but Alice is in total shock. "He went on talking, but I didn't hear. I found myself crawling down through the seats in the bleachers, pushing aside people's feet to make room." (p. 155). For many students today, this is unfortunately something they've heard about either locally or on the news, but to see Alice experience it is still emotional and visceral. It leaves readers shaken.
Denise's death happens at the end of the book, and Alice definitely isn't okay by the final scene. She is contemplative, wondering what she could have done differently. In the end, she realizes "...all we can do is be the best friends to each other that we can and hope it's enough." (p.159). Growing up is never easy, and Naylor's willingness to share this struggle is just one of the things I love about this series.
Alice in April. Phyllis Reynolds Naylor. Atheneum Books for Young Readers, 1993.
borrowed from Lewis & Clark library
Saturday, September 10, 2011
Hold Me Closer, Necromancer
I was going to start this post in the same way I start many posts. I tend to tell you what I don’t like about a genre and then tell you about an exception. And just maybe I’ve been wrong about what I really like. Maybe what I like isn’t a particular genre, I really just like a well-written book and a good plot.
Hold Me Closer, Necromancer was on last year’s William C. Morris Debut YA Award shortlist. I finally got around to reading it recently. I am tired of supernatural books being all the rage, and this advertises its supernaturality right in the title. It seems like every other book coming out this year is supernatural fiction. On my nightstand right now I have a historical fiction title concerning magic, a book about werewolves and an adult title about vampires…and I’m not actively seeking out supernatural fiction! So it has to be pretty special for me to really feel like it’s worth bringing to your attention.
Sam begins this book working in a fast food restaurant. He has friends, but he’s always felt different than everyone else. Sam (whose real name is Samhain) has dropped out of college and has given up trying to find his “thing” in life. But then an ill-fated game of potato hockey in the parking lot brings a very creepy man into the restaurant. The man starts accusing Sam of being and doing things Sam doesn’t understand. Is it coincidence that the pouch of herbs Sam’s mother gave him, that he always wears around his neck, has broken that night?
One of my teen librarian friends says that Sam is one of the hottest teen male characters this year, and maybe that will get some of you to pick up the book. It’s set in Seattle (where the author is from) and maybe that will get some of you to read it too. Here’s what I think makes this book unputdownable…everything. Sam is a great character. Although he is a slacker, and can’t seem to find his groove in life, Sam is witty and clever. He has a group of friends who are willing to just let him be himself – they are just along for the ride. He has already dropped out of college, making him older than the normal teen hero, but he does have the typical teen problems. He is trying to find himself, and nothing has ever seemed right. Sam is human and relatable, even though he can commune with the dead. A creepy situation, but not a creepy guy.
I dare you not to hum along to Elton John’s “Tiny Dancer” while you read this. That’s not the only song title or lyric that McBride uses in a clever way in this novel. All of the chapter titles are from songs as well. They fit each chapter’s contents perfectly – they are witty and smart. I can’t imagine how long it must have taken to come up with the perfect matches.
One of the other things that makes this novel stand out is its fresh take on the supernatural. As the book goes on, many of the themes emerge that are in other supernatural books – uncovering the main character’s latent power, the battle between good and evil. But McBride’s talent is in making Sam’s journey seem fresh and unlike what we have read before. Sure, there is a Council, made up of representatives from several families – werewolves, the fey, necromancers, witches. But it’s the characters within these families that make this novel interesting. All of these characters are slightly quirky, but are strong, too. They are willing to fight for what they love. Sam’s friends fight to save him from a powerful necromancer because he is important to them – which says something about all of them.
And really, there is (among other hilarious/gross touches) a severed talking head and a zombie panda in this book. It’s got the gore and death and action you would expect from a supernatural book. It is a real winner, so pick it up today, especially if you love the supernatural. I have to return it, though, to get “Tiny Dancer” out of my head.
Hold Me Closer, Necromancer. Lish McBride. Henry Holt, 2010.
Sunday, September 4, 2011
Reluctantly Alice
How much do I love Alice McKinley? Let me count the ways…one, two, three, four. And now here’s a fifth way.
In Reluctantly Alice, Alice McKinley is starting seventh grade. She and her friends have moved on to junior high, and I’m sure we have all felt the same way Alice feels. “Junior high sure has a way of mixing you up, tossing kids around like a giant blender.” (p. 92). Just before the summer began, Alice and her group of friends were at the top of their elementary school. Everything they did was cool and clever to the younger kids in the school. Now suddenly they are at the bottom of the barrel, watching the older kids to see what they do (9th grade boys perform a Boxer Check in front of Alice and her astonished girl friends). At the same time, these seventh graders are desperately trying not to be noticed by older kids. They aren’t sure what to do, and they feel a little overwhelmed and lost.
Alice has decided to concentrate on having everyone like her this year. She wants to be the kind of girl that causes everyone to smile when they think of her, and if anyone can do it, you get the feeling Alice can. She rarely has something mean to say, she’s fun and daring, smart and funny. Alice is honest and even her mishaps seem endearing. But almost as soon as the school year begins, Alice has an enemy. An 8th grader in some of her classes, Denise, starts to dislike Alice and begins to taunt and bully Alice. Like many bullies, Denise finds what she believes is Alice’s weakness (her mother’s death) and brings it up every chance she gets. This escalates into a serious bullying situation. Denise and her group of friends throw food, trip Alice, laugh at her…it goes on and on. And although this book was written before most of the focus on bullying in children’s literature, the solution Alice finds still rings true. She comes up with this idea on her own, one that works for her without confronting Denise in a mean way (although she certainly thinks about it), but also extends kindness to Denise. I don’t think her solution will work for everyone, but it fits Alice perfectly. I also think it will help young teens realize that there may be a solution to their bullying problem that fits them. Alice never tells a teacher about the bullying, but she does talk to her father and brother about it. They give her suggestions, and Alice’s brother Lester does show up once at the school to help Alice, but they all seem to recognize that the answer has to come from Alice.
As in most of these books, Alice, Pamela and Elizabeth (her two best friends) continue to question love, romance and their changing bodies. When Elizabeth has a pressing question that Alice tries to answer, Alice’s father steps in. Alice has a strong, honest relationship with her father and brother. They answer her questions with as much information as they think she can handle, and they know what to do if they don’t have answers to her questions. Thus is set up one of my favorite scenes in this series so far. Alice’s father takes Alice to the library, and allows her to research the answer to Elizabeth’s question herself. When Alice is in the library stacks, “A librarian came by to get a book from the shelf, and she couldn’t help but see what I was looking at; she didn’t even blink. Like it was okay to be curious.” (p. 90) These are librarians at their most professional – they treat Alice respectfully and as an adult. I love seeing librarians in such a positive light. I love middle schoolers and teens getting to see that libraries can help answer questions in a non-judgmental way. What a terrific scene!
There are many, many other things going on in this novel, some of which are carried over from other books in the series, some of which develop in this novel. While it is definitely part of the whole series, you can pick up any Alice book and read it as a stand-alone novel. However I would bet that no matter where you started in the series, you would want to read the whole set!! I can’t say enough how much I do love Alice and the world Naylor creates in this series. For the first time, in her biography at the end of the book, Naylor writes that she plans to keep writing the Alice series until Alice turns eighteen. I’m so grateful – I can’t wait to see how Alice turns out!!
Reluctantly Alice. Phyllis Reynolds Naylor. Aladdin, 2000, ©1991.
Borrowed from the Lewis & Clark library
Tuesday, August 2, 2011
Okay for Now
When I began hearing Gary D. Schmidt’s Okay for Now mentioned over and over as a potential Newbery winner this early in the year, I can’t say I was very surprised. After all, he’s won the Newbery Honor Award twice (as well as a Printz Honor and other awards). I think you would be foolish to count him out. But I am going on record as saying if this book doesn’t win the Newbery (and possibly a Printz Award too), I’d be very surprised. It is a multi-layered narrative, combining history, family, coming-of-age and a little bit of romance and mystery. It also bridges the divide between Newbery and Printz age groups gracefully.
Schmidt takes a character from The Wednesday Wars (Doug Swieteck) and moves him from Long Island to Marysville, New York. Doug, who is going to start eighth grade, comes home one day to find out that his father has been fired after a fight with the owner of the lumber business where he works. In Marysville, Doug’s father has a friend who can get him work at the paper mill, so off they move. Doug’s father is a tough man, the kind who blusters, thinks he knows better than anyone else and isn’t afraid to let you know it. He is a drinker and there is abuse in Doug’s household. He is capable of amazing cruelty to his family, which the Swieteck boys see every day. Each of them deal with this differently, and Doug mostly handles it by keeping his head down or disappearing when it’s a “wrong day”.
When they get to Marysville, Doug happens across the Marysville Free Public Library on a Saturday, the only day it’s open each week. And it’s there that he sees the most amazing picture of a bird he has ever seen. A librarian, Mr. Powell, tells Doug the book is Audubon’s Birds of America and Doug is mesmerized. His regular visits to the bird portraits in a glass case lead to Mr. Powell teaching Doug how to draw. He practices his skills using the portraits of the birds. As Doug learns the techniques Audubon used to create the birds, he also learns to observe closely and to analyze exactly what makes the drawings so compelling. The chapters are all named after birds Doug sees and draws, and I found it very helpful that reproductions of the plates are included in Schmidt’s book. Many of the birds were not familiar to me, and as Doug describes their magnificence, readers can go back and see what he is describing for themselves.
There are so many tightly-woven details that make up Doug’s story, and I don’t want to ruin the experience for you. Suffice to say that every story Doug retells and every detail included in this narrative counts. Doug’s oldest brother, Lucas, is serving in the Vietnam War when the novel begins, helping to set the historical period. But what I believe is one of Schmidt’s greatest skills is his ability to totally craft a historical era, along with period details, but allow the narrative’s themes to be very contemporary in feel and tone. Doug is also telling the story to the reader, which feels more contemporary to me. His tough-guy demeanor (learned at home) gradually gives way to a different way of talking to the reader as the novel moves on, and it is a good indicator of the changes in Doug.
One of the themes in this coming-of-age novel is judgment and how that can be accurate or inaccurate. The Swieteck boys are perceived as no-good troublemakers when they arrive. Or at least, the middle brother, Christopher, is. He is repeatedly questioned by the police about a series of burglaries. It does seem as if there is some evidence pointing to his involvement, but Christopher always insists he is innocent. In the meantime, Doug is judged by his teachers, the principal and other townspeople just because he is the brother of a troublemaker.
Another theme in this book is faith – not the religion type of faith, but faith in Doug. Because as the year goes on, more and more townspeople begin to show faith in Doug. It begins with Mr. Powell , who sees something in Doug’s careful viewing of Birds in America that makes him take Doug under his wing, so to speak. There is Doug’s science teacher, who tells Doug directly that it doesn’t matter what his brother does, it matters what Doug does. There is the police officer’s family on his grocery delivery route who asks Doug to babysit their children. This is a town full of people who get to know Doug and see his potential. And as he is recognized for his good qualities, you begin to see a change in Doug. He begins to break out of the mold he seems destined for at the beginning of the novel.
This book is breathtaking, both in its cruelty and its hope. You root for Doug from the beginning, but as you get to know his family and the town of Marysville, you want them all to succeed. I strongly believe this should be on every Mock Newbery and Printz list (Glendale Public Library, I’m talking to you!) this year. Its combination of historical fiction, coming-of-age story and layered family narrative are compelling and exquisite. Read it now – don’t wait until it wins a medal.
Okay for Now. Gary D. Schmidt. Clarion Books, 2011.
Wednesday, June 1, 2011
Alice in Rapture, Sort Of
“Somehow life seemed to be rushing ahead faster than I was ready for. I’d barely get comfortable with one thing, and then – bam!- something new was happening.” (p. 122-3)
This quote, to me, is the core of the appeal of the Alice series. Don’t we all feel like this? It serves to remind us adults that we aren’t the only ones who feel like life is always changing. And it helps comfort girls who feel like they are the only ones among their group of friends who aren’t ready to have things change.
If you’re a regular follower of my blog, you know that the character of Alice McKinley has really struck a chord with me since the first book I read in this series many years ago. I had read various books in the series over the years, but I decided I wanted to start Alice’s journey from the beginning of her preteen years. I’ve already started blogging about the series here, hereand here.
This is the summer between Alice’s 6th and 7th grade years, and at the beginning, Alice feels that it is going to be a great summer. She has two really great friends, Pamela and Elizabeth, and a boyfriend, Patrick. Pamela’s cousin from New Jersey told Pamela that they need to start junior high with boyfriends in order to be accepted, so this becomes “The Summer of the First Boyfriend” according to Alice’s father.
And having a boyfriend requires a whole new set of social skills for the girls. Since Alice has had all year to grow her friendship with the other girls, Naylor uses this novel to help Alice find her way with Patrick. These are still young girls, so the most that goes on here is French kissing. But each girl has a boyfriend during this summer, and they all make different relationship decisions. Patrick and Alice see each other almost every day, mostly spending time on her front porch talking and holding hands. Elizabeth believe that she shouldn’t even kiss a boy (because her parents have told her she is not allowed to date) and Pamela’s mother has threatened to cut off Pamela’s extremely long hair if she dates anyone. Pamela decides to risk her mother’s anger and keep her boyfriend, but Elizabeth’s boyfriend breaks up with her when she won’t kiss him.
Patrick and Alice do lots of things together, including a supervised vacation at the beach, a fancy date at the country club and lots of time spent hanging out with their group of friends. In other words, this is an appropriate romance for young teens – there is no pressure to do anything uncomfortable at this point in the series, and the teens are having a good time together without getting into trouble. And when Alice decides that she would rather not have a boyfriend at the beginning of school, they downgrade to “special friends” without too much fuss.
One of the biggest topics in this series is Alice’s mother, who died when Alice was five. Alice is always evaluating her mother’s absence and her impact on Alice’s life. There are some real bittersweet moments in this novel. Alice discovers a box of her mom’s memorabilia in their attic while looking for some clothes. This brings her closer to her mother as it triggers some of Alice own memories (she hasn’t remembered much about her mother previously). It also helps Alice begin to know her mother as a woman and a mother.
However, as a motherless girl, there are times when Alice really feels left out. In this book she begins to find that there are substitute mothers in her life – her Aunt Sally and cousin Carol, who give her advice on what to give Patrick for his birthday; a neighbor who happens to show up when Alice is home sick with the flu; some of her older brother’s girlfriends…Alice isn’t alone. And in fact, she has many strong women in her life to help her. She just has to know where to look.
This series is so rewarding. Every time I dive into one, I read it within an afternoon. They are comforting and also address the anxiety of change. It is a feeling we can all relate to, and that’s part of the reason I keep coming back.
Alice in Rapture, Sort Of. Phyllis Reynolds Naylor. Atheneum, 1989.
Thursday, March 3, 2011
The Agony of Alice
As you've seen here and here, I'm reading the Alice series by Phyllis Reynolds Naylor. I had read a few books in the series and loved them, and I'd always intended to read them all. The Agony of Alice was the first book in the series, written in 1985.
It takes place after Alice, her father and older brother have moved to Silver Spring. Alice will be beginning sixth grade in a new school - a daunting task for anyone. Alice is no exception - she is looking at herself and feeling very self-conscious. She is embarrassed by some of the situations she finds herself in - like when she asked a neighbor to play Tarzan and Jane with her so she could kiss him, and then changed her mind at the last minute. Naylor is very tuned in to Alice's tween personality and fluctuating emotions, and I think any girl of this age will relate to Alice. Even as an adult, I can remember feeling self-conscious, awkward and unsure of myself at Alice's age.
However what makes Alice different than most girls is the absence of her mother. While Alice's mom died seven years ago, when Alice was four, but that doesn't mean that Alice misses her any less at this point in her life. In fact, Alice is sure that a mother would have helped steer her away from the embarrassing situations Alice seems to find herself in. Her mother's death is part of what makes up Alice's personality. I love that Lester (who is older, and thus remembers their mother more clearly) shares his memories with Alice, who remembers very little of her. The family spends a lot of time bringing their mother to life - a healthy way to grieve but also honor her.
As these books go on, it is evident that Alice's father is slightly out of depth with Alice. Alice gets her period in this novel, and luckily it happens at her aunt's house. When she gets home, her dad mentions it awkwardly, and Alice knows that however she feels about it, she wants to make her father comfortable. She reassures him matter of factly that everything's okay, and he is visibly relieved.
Alice finds herself grasping for guidance that she might have gotten from her mother. She is disappointed when she arrives at her new school to find she's been assigned to Mrs. Plotkin's room. She instantly dislikes Mrs. Plotkin, based on her name and shape. Alice wants nothing more than to be in the beautiful, young teacher's classroom, but as the year progresses, Mrs. Plotkin turns out to be the teacher Alice needs and much more. The name Mrs. Plotkin is so evocative, but her true personality is revealed and she is wonderful. Naylor provides a gentle lesson for readers, but in a warm way.
Many of the recurring characters in this series are already onstage in this novel - Alice's father has memorable female employees vying for his attention; Lester has two girlfriends who he will go back and forth between throughout the series. Alice is observing what it is like to be a woman in all these situations, and it is a diverse group that influences her. Alice has already met the girls who will be her best friends, Pamela and Elizabeth. And then there's Patrick, Alice's "boyfriend" - "On the way to school the next morning, Patrick threw another candy bar toward me, a Three Musketeers. This time I was so nervous I dropped it,...and after that , I guess we were going together." (p. 94) So sixth grade!!
This book introduces new feelings and ideas to tween girls, but it is done in such a friendly, comforting way. Yet another terrific book about growing up by Naylor.
The Agony of Alice. Phyllis Reynolds Naylor. Atheneum Books for Young Readers, 1985.
borrowed from Lewis & Clark Library
It takes place after Alice, her father and older brother have moved to Silver Spring. Alice will be beginning sixth grade in a new school - a daunting task for anyone. Alice is no exception - she is looking at herself and feeling very self-conscious. She is embarrassed by some of the situations she finds herself in - like when she asked a neighbor to play Tarzan and Jane with her so she could kiss him, and then changed her mind at the last minute. Naylor is very tuned in to Alice's tween personality and fluctuating emotions, and I think any girl of this age will relate to Alice. Even as an adult, I can remember feeling self-conscious, awkward and unsure of myself at Alice's age.
However what makes Alice different than most girls is the absence of her mother. While Alice's mom died seven years ago, when Alice was four, but that doesn't mean that Alice misses her any less at this point in her life. In fact, Alice is sure that a mother would have helped steer her away from the embarrassing situations Alice seems to find herself in. Her mother's death is part of what makes up Alice's personality. I love that Lester (who is older, and thus remembers their mother more clearly) shares his memories with Alice, who remembers very little of her. The family spends a lot of time bringing their mother to life - a healthy way to grieve but also honor her.
As these books go on, it is evident that Alice's father is slightly out of depth with Alice. Alice gets her period in this novel, and luckily it happens at her aunt's house. When she gets home, her dad mentions it awkwardly, and Alice knows that however she feels about it, she wants to make her father comfortable. She reassures him matter of factly that everything's okay, and he is visibly relieved.
Alice finds herself grasping for guidance that she might have gotten from her mother. She is disappointed when she arrives at her new school to find she's been assigned to Mrs. Plotkin's room. She instantly dislikes Mrs. Plotkin, based on her name and shape. Alice wants nothing more than to be in the beautiful, young teacher's classroom, but as the year progresses, Mrs. Plotkin turns out to be the teacher Alice needs and much more. The name Mrs. Plotkin is so evocative, but her true personality is revealed and she is wonderful. Naylor provides a gentle lesson for readers, but in a warm way.
Many of the recurring characters in this series are already onstage in this novel - Alice's father has memorable female employees vying for his attention; Lester has two girlfriends who he will go back and forth between throughout the series. Alice is observing what it is like to be a woman in all these situations, and it is a diverse group that influences her. Alice has already met the girls who will be her best friends, Pamela and Elizabeth. And then there's Patrick, Alice's "boyfriend" - "On the way to school the next morning, Patrick threw another candy bar toward me, a Three Musketeers. This time I was so nervous I dropped it,...and after that , I guess we were going together." (p. 94) So sixth grade!!
This book introduces new feelings and ideas to tween girls, but it is done in such a friendly, comforting way. Yet another terrific book about growing up by Naylor.
The Agony of Alice. Phyllis Reynolds Naylor. Atheneum Books for Young Readers, 1985.
borrowed from Lewis & Clark Library
Monday, October 11, 2010
All We Know of Love
Natalie has lived with her father for the past four years, four months and fifteen days. Since the day her mother walked out the door in the middle of a sentence and never looked back. This has, of course, totally shaped the teenager Natalie has become. She is fairly disconnected from her father and has stopped sharing anything real about herself with anyone. Instead she gives each of the people in her life (including her best friend and boyfriend) little glimpses of herself. Natalie is surely heading for trouble when she lies to her father about going on a trip with her best friend. Instead she hops on a bus down the East Coast to ask her mother to complete the sentence she never finished – it was something about love.
Road trips are a classic theme in young adult literature (off the top of my head, one of my favorites is in An Abundance of Katherines). Many coming of age stories happen during road trips, as the road seems to give teenagers the freedom to really discover themselves, especially when there are no parents around to tell them what to do and how to do it. All We Know of Love takes place during the 24 hour trip to St. Augustine, Florida. Natalie doesn’t really plan this trip extensively, and so she has little money, no food, and a cell phone rapidly running out of battery when she leaves. Her decision not to buy snacks in the Stamford, Connecticut bus station leads to a side trip through Maryland when her bus leaves her stranded at a small diner. While Natalie is certainly on her own on this trip, she is not without adults to help her complete her journey.
The whole novel is about love – between Natalie and her parents, between Natalie and her best friend Sarah, between Natalie and her boyfriend, Adam. But I especially like how Baskin gives us a look into other characters’ perspectives on love. Each of the characters who touch Natalie’s life on this trip reflects on love within different chapters along her journey. Natalie may not ever hear their backstory, but we are privy to some of it. For instance, there is the young runaway in the Baltimore bus station, whose younger sister has died, leaving her feeling confused and unloved. These short narratives within Natalie’s journey influence how we continue to read Natalie’s story. This is a creative way to keep the story from being told wholly from Natalie’s perspective, thus limiting our understanding of love to Natalie’s understanding. These characters are all memorable and unique, and add layers to Natalie’s journey.
Another addition to our understanding of Natalie’s trip are the quotes at the beginning of each chapter. Each quote is about love, but also gives a subtle hint about what will take place . For example, a dictionary quote on the connection between friendship and love leads a chapter where Natalie betrays her best friend for her boyfriend, and another character reminisces about an old friendship.
This book is delicately written and beautifully told. You can’t help reading to find out not only what will happen with Natalie’s mother at the end of her journey, but also if Natalie will find herself. I haven’t really written about Natalie’s relationship with her older, manipulative boyfriend, but you really root for Natalie to recognize her own desperation and arrive at a new place of strength. At the end of her journey, Natalie doesn’t get the answers she expects, but it is definitely worth the trip.
All We Know of Love - Nora Raleigh Baskin. Candlewick, 2008. Borrowed from Lewis & Clark Library.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)
